| PLAYER | POSITION | YEAR | TEAM |
|---|---|---|---|
| OFFENSE FIRST TEAM | |||
| Jacob Simons (POY) | QB | Jr | Lake Country |
| Alec Grimmer | RB | Sr | Messmer/Shorewood |
| Cameron Werner | RB | Jr | Living Word |
| Jacob Demman | WR | Sr | Lake Country |
| Jake Kolasinski | WR | Sr | Brookfield Academy |
| Jonathan Carson | TE | Jr | Messmer/Shorewood |
| Tim Bahr | OT | Sr | Lake Country |
| Tim Martens | OT | Sr | Lake Country |
| Evan Dittmann | OG | Sr | Lake Country |
| Corey Gipson | OG | Sr | Messmer/Shorewood |
| Nicholas Lies | C | Jr | SJNMA |
| Bobby Kohl | K | Sr | Messmer/Shorewood |
| OFFENSE SECOND TEAM | |||
| Taylor Dennis | QB | Jr | Messmer/Shorewood |
| Dominic Pfister | RB | Sr | SJNMA |
| Anthony Poe | RB | Sr | Hope Christian |
| JR Ellison | WR | Sr | Lake Country |
| Chris Cooper | WR | Jr | University School |
| Tristan Debow | TE | Sr | Living Word |
| Joel Rich | OT | Jr | Living Word |
| Dan Taylor | OT | Sr | University School |
| David Redwood | OG | Sr | SJNMA |
| Shaquille Allen | OG | Sr | SJNMA |
| Nick Hardy | C | Sr | Hope Christian |
| Ben Wilkins | K | Jr | Lake Country |
| DEFENSE FIRST TEAM | |||
| Ross Gottschalk | DT | Jr | Lake Country |
| Rodney Neely | DT | Jr | Messmer/Shorewood |
| Tim Bahr (POY) | DE | Sr | Lake Country |
| Jonathan Carson | DE | Jr | Messmer/Shorewood |
| Nate Coss | LB | Jr | Lake Country |
| Alec Grimmer | LB | Sr | Messmer/Shorewood |
| Shaquille Allen | LB | Sr | SJNMA |
| Jake Kolasinski | LB | Sr | Brookfield Academy |
| Jacob Demman | DB | Sr | Lake Country |
| Jacob Simons | DB | Jr | Lake Country |
| Raymund Pierce | DB | So | Messmer/Shorewood |
| Dominic Pfister | DB | Sr | SJNMA |
| Dominic Pfister | P | Sr | SJNMA |
| DEFENSE SECOND TEAM | |||
| Phil Steigerwald | DT | Jr | Brookfield Academy |
| Julien Addison | DT | Sr | University School |
| Joel Rich | DE | Jr | Living Word |
| Dan Taylor | DE | Sr | University School |
| Mykyo Evans | LB | Jr | Messmer/Shorewood |
| Tyler Maas | LB | Sr | Living Word |
| Kyle Herdt | LB | Jr | Lake Country |
| Toran Marks | LB | Sr | University School |
| Donovan Freeman | DB | Sr | Messmer/Shorewood |
| Eric Imel | DB | Jr | SJNMA |
| Aaron Morris | DB | Jr | Hope Christian |
| Tywan Ramsey | DB | Jr | Messmer/Shorewood |
| Zach Erickson | P | So | University School |
