| PLAYER | POSITION | YEAR | TEAM |
|---|---|---|---|
| OFFENSE FIRST TEAM | |||
| Brandon Matz | QB | Jr | East Troy |
| Zeke Emerick | RB | Sr | Jefferson |
| Michael Johnson | RB | Sr | Evansille/Albany |
| Jacob Grams | RB | Sr | Edgerton |
| Lucas Gregory | WR | Jr | Edgerton |
| Nate Dodge (POY) | WR | Sr | East Troy |
| Jalen McGraw | TE | Sr | Jefferson |
| Riley Cotter | OL | Sr | Jefferson |
| Trevor Tway | OL | Sr | Evansille/Albany |
| Josh Chenoweth | OL | Jr | Evansille/Albany |
| Billy Buth | OL | Sr | Jefferson |
| Kale George | OL | Sr | Evansille/Albany |
| Chris Wedel | K | Sr | McFarland |
| OFFENSE SECOND TEAM | |||
| Dustin Moldenhauer | QB | Sr | Jefferson |
| Zach Miles | RB | Sr | Whitewater |
| Joey Dedick | RB | Sr | East Troy |
| Nick Perkl | RB | Sr | McFarland |
| Adam Converse | WR | Jr | Edgerton |
| Cody Zaeske | WR | Sr | East Troy |
| Chris Wedel | WR | Sr | McFarland |
| Owen Schonenberger | TE | Sr | Evansille/Albany |
| Conner Learn | OL | Sr | Edgerton |
| Brad Stoll | OL | Jr | Whitewater |
| Alex Kazmierski | OL | Sr | East Troy |
| Brett Schoenherr | OL | Sr | Jefferson |
| Ben Kregness | OL | Sr | McFarland |
| Daniel Fabricius | K | Jr | Evansille/Albany |
| DEFENSE FIRST TEAM | |||
| Billy Buth | DL | Sr | Jefferson |
| Owen Schonenberger (POY) | DL | Sr | Evansille/Albany |
| Alex Kazmierski | DL | Sr | East Troy |
| Jalen McGraw | DE | Sr | Jefferson |
| Nick Felske | DE | Sr | East Troy |
| Mac Renz | LB | Jr | Jefferson |
| Jacob Grams | LB | Sr | Edgerton |
| Kale George | LB | Sr | Evansille/Albany |
| Nate Dodge | LB | Sr | East Troy |
| Zeke Emerick | DB | Sr | Jefferson |
| Austin Hill | DB | Sr | Evansille/Albany |
| Chris Wedel | DB | Sr | McFarland |
| Andy Cooper | P | So | Whitewater |
| DEFENSE SECOND TEAM | |||
| Josh Kyle | DL | Sr | Whitewater |
| Evan Benedict | DL | Sr | Evansille/Albany |
| Dakota Bira | DL | Sr | East Troy |
| Collin Beasley | DE | Jr | Edgerton |
| Sawyer Johnson | DE | Sr | Evansille/Albany |
| Mike Kevin | LB | Sr | Jefferson |
| Nick Perkl | LB | Sr | McFarland |
| Eagan Keeley | LB | Sr | McFarland |
| Lucas Gregory | LB | Jr | Edgerton |
| Austin Muszynski | LB | Sr | East Troy |
| Isaac Hanson | DB | Sr | Edgerton |
| Tanner Braunschweig | DB | Sr | East Troy |
| Brandon Doll | DB | Sr | McFarland |
| Nate Dodge | P | Sr | East Troy |
| HONORABLE MENTION | |||
| Peter Linsley | Sr | Edgerton | |
| Spencer Stone | Sr | Edgerton | |
| Justin Smith | Sr | Edgerton | |
| David Jenkins | Sr | Evansille/Albany | |
| Isaiah Shell | Jr | Evansille/Albany | |
| Taylor Bochenstedt | Sr | Evansille/Albany | |
| Heath Renz | Jr | Jefferson | |
| Garrett Blaeske | So | Jefferson | |
| Tyler Clothier | Jr | Jefferson | |
| Casey Engelhart | Sr | McFarland | |
| Antwon Washington | Sr | McFarland | |
| Collin Klein | Sr | McFarland | |
| Matt Miller | Jr | East Troy | |
| Charlie Kutschenreuter | So | East Troy | |
| Brett Nowatske | Sr | East Troy | |
| Wendel Welter | Sr | Whitewater | |
| Sung-Min Kang | Sr | Whitewater | |
| Shane Peterson | Sr | Whitewater |
