| NAME | SCHOOL | YEAR |
|---|---|---|
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| Logan Sullivan | Johnson Creek | 12 -- U |
| Cal Fisher | Deerfield | 11 -- U |
| Dayton Lasack | Deerfield | 12 -- U |
| Trey Oswald | Parkview | 12 -- U |
| Brent Schmiesing | ALCS/St. Ambrose | 12 |
| Henry Manenlli | Williams Bay | 12 |
| Colin Young | Madison Country Day | 12 |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| Tommy Lees | Deerfield | 11 |
| Owen King | Williams Bay | 11 |
| Kelton Randall | Williams Bay | 11 |
| Johnathan Loomans | ALCS/St. Ambrose | 11 |
| Dylan Bredlow | Johnson Creek | 10 |
| Austin Anton-Pernat | Johnson Creek | 12 |
| Brady Koopman | Palmyra-Eagle | 12 |
| HONORABLE MENTION | ||
| Martin Kimmel | Deerfield | 10 |
| Jimmitrius Davison | ALCS/St. Ambrose | 10 |
| Dalton Metzdorf | Palmyra-Eagle | 12 |
| Rusty Klitzman | Parkview | 11 |
| Noah Flood-Elyafi | Parkview | 12 |
| Zander Brown | Parkview | 12 |
| Stephen Bosben | Madison Country Day | 12 |
| PLAYER OF THE YEAR | ||
| Logan Sullivan | Johnson Creek | 12 |