| NAME | YEAR | SCHOOL |
|---|---|---|
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| Lauren Cleary | Jr. | Lake Country Lutheran |
| Rieley Mueller | Sr. | Lake Country Lutheran |
| Mya Hartjes (POY) | Jr. | University School |
| Brooke Bluhm | Sr. | Heritage Christian |
| Audrey Heiring | Frosh. | Kenosha Christian |
| Kyana Aguilera | Jr. | St. Francis |
| Elise Raymond | Soph. | Living Word Lutheran |
| Ar’Niyah Terry | Jr. | Messmer |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| Haydn Hahm | Jr. | Lake Country Lutheran |
| Ava Petersen | Frosh. | Lake Country Lutheran |
| Erika Schuh | Soph. | University School |
| Ava Dyke | Jr. | University School |
| Jacque Dieck | Sr. | Brookfield Academy |
| Patricia Weiss | Soph. | Brookfield Academy |
| Morgan Bluhm | Soph. | Heritage Christian |
| Aynsley Czekalski | Frosh. | St. Francis |
| Emmah Bagin | Sr. | Living Word Lutheran |
| HONORABLE MENTION | ||
| Addie Reimer | Jr. | Lake Country Lutheran |
| Abby Sisson | Jr. | University School |
| Sydnie Dehne | Jr. | Brookfield Academy |
| Lucia Jensen | Soph. | Brookfield Academy |
| Haley Millen | Jr. | Heritage Christian |
| Faith Bozman | Frosh. | Kenosha Christian |
| POY = Player of the Year |