| PLAYER | POSITION | YEAR | TEAM |
|---|---|---|---|
| OFFENSE FIRST TEAM | |||
| Connor Senger (POY) | QB | Sr | Pius XI |
| T.J. Watt | QB | Sr | Pewaukee |
| Mickey Morgan | RB | Sr | Wauwatosa West |
| Ryan Stepanovich | RB | Jr | Pewaukee |
| Jameson Brock | RB | Jr | Wauwatosa West |
| Jake Zywicki | RB | Sr | Greendale |
| David Girmscheid | RB | Sr | Pewaukee |
| Mitchell Brees | WR | Jr | Greendale |
| Darrius Nance | WR | Sr | Pius XI |
| Develyn Ferguson | WR | Jr | Wauwatosa West |
| Peter Pekar | TE | Sr | Greendale |
| Jamison Cook (LOY) | OL | Sr | Pewaukee |
| Sam Bryan | OL | Sr | Greendale |
| Brandon Hart | OL | Sr | Greendale |
| Paul Graber | OL | Sr | New Berlin Eisenhower |
| Ron Brown | OL | Sr | Wauwatosa West |
| Adam Polivka | OL | Sr | Wauwatosa West |
| Kevin Baumann | OL | Sr | Pewaukee |
| Brett Connors | OL | Jr | New Berlin West |
| Nathan Erickson | K | Jr | New Berlin Eisenhower |
| OFFENSE HONORABLE MENTION | |||
| Josh Ringelberg | QB | So | Greendale |
| Jared Morzinski | QB | Jr | Wauwatosa West |
| Nick Taylor | RB | Jr | New Berlin Eisenhower |
| Dylan Wiese | RB | Jr | New Berlin West |
| Bryan Watson | RB | Jr | New Berlin West |
| George Opelt | RB | Sr | Pewaukee |
| Anthony Miosi | RB | Sr | Pewaukee |
| Bernardo Solano | RB | Jr | Pius XI |
| Greg Lewis | RB | Jr | Wauwatosa West |
| Cody Kmetz | WR | So | Greendale |
| Nick Holicek | WR | Sr | New Berlin Eisenhower |
| Dan Kemp | WR | Sr | Pewaukee |
| Jesse Johnston | OL | Sr | Greendale |
| Chris Halbur | OL | Jr | Greendale |
| Zach Bernaden | OL | Sr | New Berlin Eisenhower |
| Spencer Stanfield | OL | Jr | New Berlin West |
| Lukas Lauer | OL | Jr | New Berlin West |
| Kevin Thiessenhusen | OL | Jr | New Berlin West |
| Kyle Baumann | OL | Sr | Pewaukee |
| Craig Egle | OL | Sr | Wauwatosa West |
| Dakota Kolatski | OL | Sr | Wauwatosa West |
| Frankie Rutkowski | K | Jr | Greendale |
| DEFENSE FIRST TEAM | |||
| Matt Ottman | DL | Jr | Pewaukee |
| Jacob Roseland | DL | Jr | Pewaukee |
| Khaled Salem | DL | Sr | Wauwatosa West |
| Lukas Lauer | DL | Jr | New Berlin West |
| Peter Pekar | DE/OLB | Sr | Greendale |
| T.J. Watt | DE/OLB | Sr | Pewaukee |
| Eric Lutzen | DE/OLB | Jr | Pewaukee |
| Matt Hewitt | DE/OLB | Sr | New Berlin West |
| David Girmscheid (POY) | ILB | Sr | Pewaukee |
| Turner Sagat | ILB | Sr | New Berlin Eisenhower |
| Nate Miller | ILB | Jr | Greendale |
| Bryce Leszczynski | ILB | Jr | Pius XI |
| Jon Doolen | ILB | Sr | Wauwatosa West |
| Jameson Brock | DB | Jr | Wauwatosa West |
| Derek Folkert | DB | Sr | Pewaukee |
| Mickey Morgan | DB | Sr | Wauwatosa West |
| Mitchell Brees | DB | Jr | Greendale |
| Nick Holicek | DB | Sr | New Berlin Eisenhower |
| Austin Schroeder | DB | Sr | Pewaukee |
| T.J. Watt | P | Sr | Pewaukee |
| DEFENSE HONORABLE MENTION | |||
| Anthony Stewart | DL | Sr | New Berlin Eisenhower |
| Kevin Baumann | DL | Sr | Pewaukee |
| Shawn Connors | DL | Sr | Wauwatosa West |
| Sam Clough | DL | Sr | Wauwatosa West |
| Frankie Rutkowski | DE/OLB | Jr | Greendale |
| Zach Henderson | DE/OLB | Jr | Greendale |
| Nate Latus | DE/OLB | Jr | New Berlin West |
| Doug DeVoe | DE/OLB | Sr | Pewaukee |
| Eric Yanisch | DE/OLB | Sr | Pius XI |
| Niko Lewis | DE/OLB | Jr | Wauwatosa West |
| Ben Meleski | ILB | Jr | New Berlin West |
| Alex McLeod | ILB | Jr | New Berlin West |
| Greg Lewis | ILB | Jr | Wauwatosa West |
| Travis McKeon | DB | Jr | New Berlin West |
| Trenton Krickeberg | DB | Sr | New Berlin West |
| Peter Pekar | P | Sr | Greendale |
| Mickey Morgan | P | Sr | Wauwatosa West |