| PLAYER | POSITION | YEAR | TEAM |
|---|---|---|---|
| OFFENSE FIRST TEAM | |||
| Joe Ferguson | QB | Sr | Mad. Memorial |
| Alex Brown | QB | Sr | Mad. West |
| Donte Starlin-Merriam | RB | Sr | Sun Prairie |
| Dom Wise | RB | Sr | Verona |
| Jevarious Rockmore | RB | Sr | Middleton |
| Aaron Fischer | RB | Jr | Sun Prairie |
| Jester Weah | WR | Sr | Mad. Memorial |
| Terrell McFadden | WR | Jr | Mad. West |
| Mike Marchese | WR | Jr | Sun Prairie |
| Aubrey Johnson | TE | Jr | Mad. West |
| Andrew Terwilliger | OL | Sr | Verona |
| Aidan McNamara | OL | Sr | Mad. West |
| Randy Jones | OL | Sr | Sun Prairie |
| Josh Coyne | OL | Sr | Middleton |
| Justin Laridean | OL | Sr | Sun Prairie |
| Adam Stiner | OL | Jr | Verona |
| Luke Lanzendorf | OL | Sr | Mad. La Follette |
| Derek Witte | K | Sr | Verona |
| Jester Weah | KR | Sr | Mad. Memorial |
| Vernon Mems | KR | Sr | Sun Prairie |
| OFFENSE SECOND TEAM | |||
| Ryan Curran | QB | Jr | Sun Prairie |
| Dai-Von Vance-Jenkins | RB | Jr | Janesville Parker |
| Montral Davis | RB | Sr | Beloit Memorial |
| Sam Sharer | RB | Sr | Verona |
| Jared Krueger | RB | Sr | Janesville Craig |
| Derek Rongstad | WR | Jr | Middleton |
| Brynale Dean | WR | Jr | Beloit Memorial |
| Daurice Fountain | WR | Jr | Mad. Memorial |
| Kevin Karwoski | OL | Sr | Middleton |
| David Christensen | OL | Sr | Mad. Memorial |
| Justin O'Neill | OL | Jr | Beloit Memorial |
| Will Eden | OL | Sr | Janesville Craig |
| Michael Dubanowich | OL | Sr | Janesville Parker |
| Alex Matheson | OL | Sr | Sun Prairie |
| Kyle Reichert | OL | Sr | Verona |
| Daurice Fountain | KR | Jr | Mad. Memorial |
| Dustin Wunderlin | K | Jr | Sun Prairie |
| DEFENSE FIRST TEAM | |||
| Craig Evans | DL | Jr | Sun Prairie |
| Brandon Doepke | DL | Sr | Mad. West |
| Ja'Kurr Thomas | DL | Sr | Verona |
| Shane Seiter | DL | Sr | Sun Prairie |
| Reese Felton | DL | Sr | Middleton |
| Bilal Louzati | ILB | Sr | Verona |
| Mike Garvey | ILB | Jr | Sun Prairie |
| Paul Foster | ILB | Sr | Janesville Craig |
| Robert Garel | ILB | Jr | Mad. West |
| Vernon Mems | OLB | Sr | Sun Prairie |
| Emmett Turley | OLB | Sr | Middleton |
| Antonio Hoye | OLB | Jr | Mad. West |
| Jordan King | DB | Sr | Verona |
| Jeramiah Bradley | DB | Jr | Sun Prairie |
| Wes Love | DB | Sr | Sun Prairie |
| Marcus Collins | DB | Jr | Mad. La Follette |
| Sam Sharer | P | Sr | Verona |
| DEFENSE SECOND TEAM | |||
| Aswan Thompson | DL | Sr | Mad. Memorial |
| Devin Webster | DL | So | Sun Prairie |
| Lamont McCoy | DL | Sr | Mad. La Follette |
| Austin Hall | DL | Sr | Beloit Memorial |
| Jassam Saqr | DL | Sr | Verona |
| Derek Horne | ILB | Sr | Mad. La Follette |
| Malik Bondon | ILB | Jr | Sun Prairie |
| Adam Schuman | ILB | Sr | Mad. Memorial |
| Lucas Kirch | ILB | Sr | Verona |
| Ryan Bruesewitz | OLB | Jr | Mad. Memorial |
| Jake Knutdson | OLB | Sr | Sun Prairie |
| Sam Sutherland | OLB | Sr | Mad. Memorial |
| Matt Trehey | DB | Sr | Middleton |
| Nick Annin | DB | Sr | Mad. West |
| Tyler Brooks | DB | Sr | Janesville Parker |
| Joe Ferguson | DB | Sr | Mad. Memorial |
| Dustin Wunderlin | P | Jr | Sun Prairie |
| HONORABLE MENTION | |||
| Dylan Carlyle | Sr | Beloit Memorial | |
| Dylan Fields | Sr | Beloit Memorial | |
| Keegan Mickey | Jr | Beloit Memorial | |
| Edgar Ramirez | Sr | Beloit Memorial | |
| Reilly West | Sr | Beloit Memorial | |
| Erik Davis | Sr | Janesville Craig | |
| Tom Gabower | Jr | Janesville Craig | |
| Drew Grassi | Sr | Janesville Craig | |
| Paul Jacobson | Jr | Janesville Parker | |
| Mike Money | Jr | Janesville Parker | |
| Mat Pakes | Sr | Janesville Parker | |
| Noah Seichter | Jr | Janesville Parker | |
| Tyler Steinke | Jr | Janesville Parker | |
| Delano Bingham | Sr | Mad. East | |
| Chrisgin Fagan | Jr | Mad. East | |
| David Lafayette | Sr | Mad. East | |
| Raymond Morel | Sr | Mad. East | |
| Treveon Wright | Sr | Mad. East | |
| Trevon Ampe | Sr | Mad. La Follette | |
| Brandon Herrera | Sr | Mad. La Follette | |
| Rodney Poe | Jr | Mad. La Follette | |
| Isaac Schaefer | Sr | Mad. La Follette | |
| Troy Teigen | Sr | Mad. La Follette | |
| RaQuann Cunnigan | Jr | Mad. Memorial | |
| Ben Horman | Jr | Mad. Memorial | |
| Darnell Richmond | Sr | Mad. Memorial | |
| Jim Sullivan | Jr | Mad. Memorial | |
| Jon Wilkins | Sr | Mad. Memorial | |
| Josh Esealuka | Sr | Mad. West | |
| Christian Graf | Jr | Mad. West | |
| Kasey Kuchenbecker | Sr | Mad. West | |
| Jaden Lechelt | Sr | Mad. West | |
| Malik Clements | Jr | Mad. West | |
| Trevor Dresen | Sr | Middleton | |
| Demond Hill | Jr | Middleton | |
| Josh Kampe | Sr | Middleton | |
| Makonnen Ramsey | Sr | Middleton | |
| Blake Wilson | Sr | Middleton | |
| Brandon Andrews | Sr | Sun Prairie | |
| Mike Hommerding | Sr | Sun Prairie | |
| Drew Mikalofsky | Sr | Sun Prairie | |
| AJ Radwill | Sr | Sun Prairie | |
| Devan Ziegel | Sr | Sun Prairie | |
| Nick Fish | Sr | Verona | |
| Zach Jones | Sr | Verona | |
| Trevor Kermicle | Sr | Verona | |
| Eric Koberle | Sr | Verona | |
| Mike Krantz | Sr | Verona |
