| PLAYER | POSITION | YEAR | TEAM |
|---|---|---|---|
| OFFENSE FIRST TEAM | |||
| Peter Krien (POY) | QB | Sr | Badger |
| Robert Johnson | RB | Sr | Badger |
| Alex Thomaschek | RB | Sr | Waterford |
| Matt Christensen | WR | Sr | Wilmot |
| Kasey Solofra | WR | Sr | Burlington |
| Ty Dennis | TE | Sr | Burlington |
| Logan Tenney | OL | Jr | Badger |
| Brandon Miller | OL | Sr | Waterford |
| Luke Hesse | OL | Jr | Burlington |
| JJ Pryzbylka | OL | Sr | Waterford |
| Paul Swartz | OL | Sr | Wilmot |
| Spencer Warner | K | Sr | Burlington |
| OFFENSE SECOND TEAM | |||
| Jayden Essman | QB | Sr | Burlington |
| Bennett Kothe | RB | Sr | Wilmot |
| Chad Redmer | RB | Sr | Burlington |
| Stephen Rodriguez | WR | Jr | Delavan-Darien |
| Luke Millhouse | WR | Sr | Westosha Central |
| Luke Gorst | TE | Sr | Elkhorn |
| Carlos Garcia | OL | Sr | Badger |
| Austin Gillmore | OL | Sr | Westosha Central |
| Quentin Cauffman | OL | Sr | Elkhorn |
| Brandon Schindler | OL | Sr | Waterford |
| Tyler Kirkeeng | OL | Jr | Burlington |
| Mike Hall | K | Sr | Westosha Central |
| OFFENSE HONORABLE MENTION | |||
| Noah Strasser | QB | Sr | Wilmot |
| Austin Feeney | RB | Jr | Westosha Central |
| Drew Bryson | WR | Sr | Elkhorn |
| Brad Ostrowski | WR | Sr | Union Grove |
| Erik Nevoso | TE | Sr | Wilmot |
| Noah Mishleau | OL | Jr | Union Grove |
| Heath Gascoigne | OL | Sr | Wilmot |
| Alec Henderson | OL | Jr | Waterford |
| Mike Habrel | OL | Sr | Badger |
| Brendan Huber | OL | Sr | Delavan-Darien |
| DEFENSE FIRST TEAM | |||
| Brandon Miller (POY) | DL | Sr | Waterford |
| Zach Dodge | DL | Jr | Wilmot |
| Josh Doyle | DL | Jr | Badger |
| Jake Wirsching | DL | Sr | Waterford |
| Andy Cychner | LB | Jr | Badger |
| Jake Sawyers | LB | Jr | Elkhorn |
| JJ Ahlers | LB | Sr | Waterford |
| Max Fisher | LB | So | Waterford |
| Matt Reynolds | DB | Jr | Badger |
| Chris Benavides | DB | Sr | Waterford |
| Ty Dennis | DB | Sr | Burlington |
| Michael Dilley | P | Sr | Waterford |
| Layne Hammer | DB | Sr | Hillsboro |
| DEFENSE SECOND TEAM | |||
| Luke Hesse | DL | Jr | Burlington |
| Matt Brumm | DL | Sr | Badger |
| Eliah Nelson | DL | Jr | Delavan-Darien |
| Paul Swartz | DL | Sr | Wilmot |
| Justin Schweitzer | LB | Sr | Wilmot |
| Austin Gillmore | LB | Sr | Westosha Central |
| Peter Krien | LB | Sr | Badger |
| Yianni Skapinakis | LB | Jr | Waterford |
| Trenton Bobula | DB | Sr | Badger |
| Nolan Dodge | DB | Jr | Delavan-Darien |
| Tyler Bowes | DB | Jr | Elkhorn |
| Luke Gorst | P | Sr | Elkhorn |
| DEFENSE HONORABLE MENTION | |||
| JJ Pryzbylka | DL | Sr | Waterford |
| Brandon Schindler | DL | Sr | Waterford |
| Grant Berg | DL | Jr | Elkhorn |
| Jimmy Penzel | DL | Sr | Burlington |
| John Damron | DL | Jr | Delavan-Darien |
| Andrew Allen | DL | Jr | Badger |
| Chris Lindstrand | LB | So | Wilmot |
| Alex Thomaschek | LB | Sr | Waterford |
| Ross Canales | LB | Sr | Burlington |
| Logan Mohr | LB | Sr | Elkhorn |
| Zach Biehn | LB | Jr | Westosha Central |
| Bryce Kothe | DB | So | Wilmot |
| Justin Steffens | DB | Jr | Waterford |
| Cody Jones | DB | Sr | Union Grove |
| Fred McCan | P | Sr | Union Grove |
