| PLAYER | POSITION | YEAR | TEAM |
|---|---|---|---|
| OFFENSE FIRST TEAM | |||
| Tarek Yaeggi (POY) | QB | Sr | Watertown |
| RJ Shelton | RB | Sr | Beaver Dam |
| Adihia Bell | RB | Sr | Wisconsin Lutheran |
| Sam Zwieg | WR | Sr | Watertown |
| Aaron Kumbier | WR | Jr | Watertown |
| Zach Poker | TE | Sr | Oconomowoc |
| Riley Budde | OL | Sr | Beaver Dam |
| Peter Gibson | OL | Sr | Watertown |
| Ken Reid (POY) | OL | Sr | Wisconsin Lutheran |
| Eric Marshall | OL | Sr | Wisconsin Lutheran |
| Colin Valley | OL | Jr | Oconomowoc |
| Jansen VanGrinsven | K | Sr | Wisconsin Lutheran |
| OFFENSE SECOND TEAM | |||
| Zach Evans | QB | Sr | Wisconsin Lutheran |
| Canton Larson | QB | Jr | Oconomowoc |
| DJ Spurling | RB | Sr | Slinger |
| Jacob Lauersdorf | RB | Sr | Watertown |
| Tyler Enright | WR | Sr | Oconomowoc |
| Jerry Williams | WR | Sr | Watertown |
| Dan Tarantino | TE | Sr | West Bend West |
| Mitchell Billeb | OL | Sr | Slinger |
| Matt Zeitler | OL | Jr | Wisconsin Lutheran |
| Matt Tennessen | OL | Sr | Hartford |
| Bryce Johnson | OL | Sr | Beaver Dam |
| Brent Reierson | OL | Jr | Watertown |
| OFFENSE HONORABLE MENTION | |||
| Cody Chesak | QB | Sr | West Bend West |
| Armilles Terry | RB | Sr | Hartford |
| Billy Anderson | RB | Sr | West Bend West |
| London Townsend | RB | Sr | Wisconsin Lutheran |
| Ethan Willer | WR | Jr | Hartford |
| Zach Schmidt | WR | Sr | Watertown |
| Paul Kaufmann | WR | Sr | West Bend East |
| Sean Fassbender | TE | Sr | Slinger |
| Casey Bednarski | OL | Jr | Oconomowoc |
| Dan Tokarski | OL | Sr | Oconomowoc |
| Aaron Muesch | OL | Sr | Slinger |
| Josh Mecikalski | OL | Sr | Watertown |
| Corey Parris | OL | Sr | West Bend East |
| Josh Fischer | K | Sr | Watertown |
| DEFENSE FIRST TEAM | |||
| Ken Reid | DL | Sr | Wisconsin Lutheran |
| Jason Erdmann | DL | So | Slinger |
| Owen Salzwedel | DE | Sr | Beaver Dam |
| David O'Gorman | DE | Jr | Watertown |
| Eric Marshall | ILB | Sr | Wisconsin Lutheran |
| Alex Maternowski | ILB | Jr | Slinger |
| Aaron Cramer | OLB | Sr | Oconomowoc |
| Adihia Bell | OLB | Sr | Wisconsin Lutheran |
| Shawntrell Garner | DB | Sr | Wisconsin Lutheran |
| Nick Miller | DB | Sr | Watertown |
| Jackson Boehlke | DB | Sr | Slinger |
| Jansen VanGrinsven | P | Sr | Wisconsin Lutheran |
| DEFENSE SECOND TEAM | |||
| Tyler Fogarty | DL | Sr | Oconomowoc |
| David Maule | DL | Sr | Watertown |
| Zach Poker | DE | Sr | Oconomowoc |
| Justin Wilson | DE | Sr | Wisconsin Lutheran |
| Nick Gomez | ILB | Jr | Oconomowoc |
| Mike Winkelman | ILB | Jr | Watertown |
| Alex Crogan | OLB | Sr | Watertown |
| Michael Garbers | OLB | Sr | Slinger |
| Nick Albrecht | DB | Sr | West Bend West |
| Sam Zwieg | DB | Sr | Watertown |
| DEFENSE HONORABLE MENTION | |||
| Luke Everts | DE | Sr | Hartford |
| Jack Baumann | LB | Sr | West Bend West |
| Jason Diels | LB | Jr | West Bend West |
| Eric Bould | LB | Sr | West Bend East |
| Ronnie Kraft | LB | Jr | Beaver Dam |
| Jackson Bailey | LB | Sr | Beaver Dam |
| Michael Koehn | DB | Sr | West Bend East |
| James Boden | DB | Sr | Slinger |
| Andrew Guenther | DB | Sr | Oconomowoc |
| Nate Christianson | DB | Sr | Hartford |
| Nate Nelson | DB | Sr | Beaver Dam |