| PLAYER | POSITION | YEAR | TEAM |
|---|---|---|---|
| OFFENSE FIRST TEAM | |||
| Zach Sutton | QB | Sr | Whitnall |
| Drew Worth | QB | Sr | Brown Deer |
| Justin Oliden | QB | So | South Milwaukee |
| Francisco Avila | RB | Sr | St. Francis |
| Jordan Smith | RB | Sr | Brown Deer |
| Brandon Dutcher | RB | Sr | South Milwaukee |
| Sam Mentkowski (POY) | WR | Sr | Whitnall |
| Trayvon Palmer | WR | Sr | Brown Deer |
| Evan Marlowe | WR | Sr | South Milwaukee |
| Pietro D'Amato | WR | Sr | Brown Deer |
| Patrick Wyrowski | WR | Sr | Whitnall |
| Allen Walter | TE | Jr | South Milwaukee |
| Javar Tucker (OLOY) | OL | Sr | Brown Deer |
| Tom Wawrzyniak | OL | Sr | South Milwaukee |
| Nathan Getzin | OL | Sr | Greenfield |
| Nathan Berg | OL | Jr | South Milwaukee |
| Mike Marino | OL | Sr | St. Francis |
| Jake Burkard | OL | Jr | Whitnall |
| Luke Bennett | OL | Jr | Whitnall |
| Joe Saskowski | K | Jr | South Milwaukee |
| OFFENSE HONORABLE MENTION | |||
| Xavier Copeland | RB | So | Greenfield |
| Ashton Wendler | RB | Sr | Greenfield |
| Bryan Gordon | WR | Sr | Brown Deer |
| Josh Czerwinski | WR | Jr | Greenfield |
| Nick Cimler | WR | Sr | Whitnall |
| Austin Schwark | OL | Jr | Brown Deer |
| Greg Okray | OL | Jr | Brown Deer |
| Austin Rothbauer | OL | Sr | Cudahy |
| Erik Wozniak | OL | Jr | Greenfield |
| Tony Rychlowski | OL | Jr | Greenfield |
| Brandon Wilbrandt | OL | Jr | St. Francis |
| Brian Kaebisch | OL | Sr | St. Francis |
| Josh Wilkowski | OL | Jr | South Milwaukee |
| Matias Chapa | OL | Jr | South Milwaukee |
| DEFENSE FIRST TEAM | |||
| Javar Tucker (LOY) | DL | Sr | Brown Deer |
| Bryan Honerlaw | DL | Jr | South Milwaukee |
| Drake Ambroch | DL | Jr | Whitnall |
| Nash Dathe | DL | Sr | South Milwaukee |
| Eli Streeter | DL | Jr | Greenfield |
| Zach Simuncak | DE/OLB | Jr | South Milwaukee |
| Joey Molla | DE/OLB | Jr | Greenfield |
| Kineith Lewis | DE/OLB | Sr | Brown Deer |
| Austin Rothbauer | DE/OLB | Sr | Cudahy |
| Zach Rhodes (POY) | ILB | Sr | Brown Deer |
| Tom Mitchell | ILB | Jr | South Milwaukee |
| Tyler Haim | ILB | Sr | Greenfield |
| Trevor Holmes | ILB | Sr | Greenfield |
| Michael Kremer | ILB | So | Whitnall |
| Trayvon Palmer | DB | Sr | Brown Deer |
| Evan Marlowe | DB | Sr | South Milwaukee |
| Sam Mentkowski | DB | Sr | Whitnall |
| Jordan Koutnik | DB | Sr | Greenfield |
| Pietro D'Amato | DB | Sr | Brown Deer |
| Drew Worth | P | Sr | Brown Deer |
| DEFENSE HONORABLE MENTION | |||
| Jorge Vasquez | DL | Jr | St. Francis |
| James Schutz | DL | Jr | St. Francis |
| Connor Perry | DL | Sr | Whitnall |
| Donte Harmon | DE/OLB | Sr | Brown Deer |
| Aleksander Ljubic | DE/OLB | Jr | Greenfield |
| Andrew Lindsey | DE/OLB | Jr | Whitnall |
| Jacob Freuler | ILB | Sr | Brown Deer |
| Ty Ramirez, Jr | ILB | So | Cudahy |
| Ian Betts | DB | Sr | Brown Deer |
| Zach Polfer | DB | Sr | Cudahy |
| Weston Strasser | DB | Jr | Greenfield |
| Kyle Schahczinski | DB | Sr | Greenfield |
| Michael Kaifesh | DB | Sr | Greenfield |
| Nate Stemo | DB | Sr | Whitnall |
| Ian Pribyl | P | So | South Milwaukee |